
Labour's
manifesto released yesterday got a pretty glib response from the industry (there's a good overview from the regeneration side on
Jackie Sadek's blog) but one thing that seems to have ignited regional interest is the prospect of Metro Mayors.
This would give London style powers to Leeds, Manchester and Birmingham along with a few other regional cities allowing one person to act as a champion superhero who could crack the whip much as Ken Livingstone did for London.
Centre for Cities have been lobbying for this for a while and have done a grand job of getting reactions from the likes of Ken Livingstone, Sir Howard Bernstein and Steve Norris amongst others. There's short video clips outlining what they think in full
here but below, in a nutshell, is what they said. Surprisingly, and refreshingly, given Centre for Cities is pushing for this they aren't all glowing recommendations.
Simon Fanshawe, Brighton and Hove Economic Partnership: says the Centre for Cities have been too timid and it should be extended beyond the metropolitan areas.
Sir Howard Bernstein, Manchester City council: believes the metro mayors might be meaningless if they are imposed simply on top of the existing constitutional arrangements and is calling for significant and genuine devolution of powers. However he definitely wants the discussion opened.
Steven Norris: Government by committee doesn't work and he can't think of any decisions that are made better because 65 people have made them - 65 is apparently the average number of people on an English local authority. Elected mayors as we've seen in London galvanise the city.
Ken Livingstone: Was very suspicious of mayors when Tony Blair suggested it because at any one time there are at least 50 American mayors in jail for fraud. But they allow decisions to be made quickly and without all the politicking (presumably that should read quite as much politicking).
John Shipley OBE, leader Newcastle city council
Simon Fanshawe, Brighton & Hove Economic Partnership
Sir Howard Bernstein, Manchester City Council
Steve Norris
Angie Robinson, Greater Manchester Chamber of Commerce
Ken Livingstone
: Isn't a fan and wants to see a broader city region executive made up of all the leaders of the respective councils.
Tony Travers, London School of Economics: says London has been a huge success in terms of transport and planning and thinks that should be extended out.
Picture by Percita on Flickr and used under the Creative Commons license.
Recent Comments